EARN25

History: Don't Count Out a September Rally Yet

September historically underperforms, but 2023 may catch a break

Senior Quantitative Analyst
Sep 7, 2023 at 8:00 AM
facebook X logo linkedin


Stocks have had a poor start to September, which is not surprising given that September is historically the worst month of the year for stocks. Since 1950, the S&P 500 Index (SPX) has averaged a loss of 0.66% in September, and only 44% of these returns have been positive. Since 2000, September has had the worst average return (1.51% loss) with only 48% of the returns positive. In this article, I will break down monthly returns further to see if there is any reason to believe that September has a good chance to break this norm.

iotw1sept6

iotw2sept6

September Price Action for the SPX

The chart below shows how the S&P 500 wound up at those averages above. It all seems to go wrong around Sept. 16. Both time frames (since 1950 and since 2000) are at their highest point on that date then fall precipitously during the second half of the month. The market doesn’t seem to be waiting that long this year before heading lower.

iotw3sept6

This Year Could be Different

I showed above that September has typically been a bad month for the stock market. Things change, however, when you consider the S&P 500 was up about 17% on the year through August. The table below shows how stocks have performed in September based on year-to-date return heading into the month. When the market was up by double digits, like this year, the S&P 500 averaged a gain of 0.61% with 54% of the returns being positive. That’s not extraordinary (it would rank 8th out of the 12 months since 1950) but at least it’s moving in the right direction.

iotw4sept6

Bullish returns through August have also been a good omen for the rest of the year. The table below shows September through December returns based on the year-to-date return through August. When the S&P 500 was up 10% or more, the rest of the year averaged a gain of 5.29% with an impressive 88% of the returns positive.

iotwchart5sept6

 

You Don’t Need 25 Alerts -- You Need ONE You Can Trust!

That’s the idea behind Trade of the Week, Schaeffer’s newest trade alert.

Every Monday morning before the opening bell, you’ll receive a single, expertly researched trade recommendation -- built from the same proprietary research we’ve been using for over four decades.

It’s not just a signal.

It’s a plan designed for traders who are tired of jumping from alert to alert without ever finding their edge.

No juggling alerts. No switching directions mid-week. Just one clear, expertly researched trade idea -- delivered before the market even opens.

👉 JOIN RIGHT NOW FOR JUST $1 TO GET THE NEXT TRADE!