AAL

Bearish Signal Says Retailer's Puts Could Double

American Eagle stock has run up to a historically bearish trendline

Managing Editor
Sep 9, 2019 at 11:58 AM
facebook X logo linkedin


It's been a rough start to the month for American Eagle Outfitters (NYSE:AEO), which tagged a two-year bottom of $13.66 on Sept. 4. Today, AEO is up 3% to trade at $16.32, but this could spell more trouble for the retailer later in September, if history is any guide. 

Today's rally takes the shares right up to resistance at their 60-day moving average, after a lengthy stretch below it. There have been four similar encounters with this moving average in the last three years, after which AEO stock was lower 10 days later by 8.3%, on average, per data from Schaeffer's Senior Quantitative Analyst Rocky White, with three of the four returns negative.

Daily Stock Chart AEO

What's more, implied volatilities on the equity are at low levels. The equity's Schaeffer's Volatility Index (SVI) of 42% registers in the 17th percentile of its annual range, a few notches below its two-year average SVI of 44.4%. With the stock resting on a historically bearish trendline, and short-term options unusually cheap at the moment, White's modeling shows that an at-the-money AEO put option could potentially return 141% over two weeks. In other words, prospective put buyers could more than quadruple their money on an expected 8.3% drop in the shares.

For a stock that's down 33% year-over-year, there's plenty of optimism to be unwound that could also fuel a decline. For starters, there's potential for downgrades, as six of the 11 brokerages in coverage rate the stock a "strong buy" and the consensus 12-month price target sits up at $19.27, territory not seen since June. 

Calls are also heavily preferred. The security's Schaeffer's put/call open interest ratio (SOIR) of 0.48 ranks in the bottom 3rd percentile -- show a very unusual call-skew among short-term speculators. Another decline this month could lead to an unwinding of bullish bets. 

 

Two High-Octane Trade Ideas. One Simple Goal: Intraday Profits.

Dynamite Day Trading Signals delivers two same-day options trades every week — powered by proprietary intraday analysis and 43+ years of trading expertise.

But this isn’t just another stream of alerts.

It’s a structured plan with clear entry and exit points – designed for traders who want to act fast, trade smart, and wrap up gains before the closing bell.

No guesswork. No overnight exposure – Just two well-researched setups per week — whether you prefer buying premium or selling it.

And the results speak for themselves: subscribers have locked in +245.8% total profit over the last six months (since inception!).

👉 Start your one-month trial now for just $10, and be ready for the next trade alert.