Sentiment Signal Flashing for First Time Since Election

Stocks could keep climbing a wall of worry, if history is any indicator

by Andrea Kramer

Published on Jul 15, 2019 at 1:45 PM

The S&P 500 Index (SPX) has been assailing all-time highs, soaring above the round-number 3,000 level for the first time ever last week. However, retail investors have been hesitant to adopt a bullish stance, as evidenced by the latest American Association of Individual Investors (AAII) sentiment poll. In fact, AAII data just triggered a sentiment signal not seen since the 2016 presidential election. Below, we take a look at how stocks perform when this crowd becomes overly apathetic.

In the AAII weekly survey ending July 10, the percentage of self-identified bears fell 4.9 percentage points, to 27.5% of respondents. However, most of those polled didn't migrate to the bullish camp. In fact, AAII bulls increased by just 0.5 percentage point, to 33.6%, while those with a neutral outlook on the stock market over the next six months surged 4.4 percentage points, to a 38.9% majority.

As such, the 10-week average of bears + neutral AAII respondents is now over 70% -- something we haven't seen since early November 2016, per Schaeffer's Quantitative Analyst Chris Prybal. Prior to that, you'd have to go back to October 2015 for a signal, which was the first of its kind since August 2012. Before that, this sentiment signal flashed in March-April 2009, what we now know was the post-financial crisis bottom.

SPX w AAII bears neutral

Since 1987, when the 10-week average of AAII bears + neutral respondents topped 70%, the stock market performed better than usual. Specifically, a month after these sentiment signals, the SPX was up an average of 1.9% -- more than twice its average anytime return of 0.7%. Three months later, the index was up 5.3% -- again more than double the norm -- with a positive rate of 84%.

Six months later, the broad-market barometer averaged a gain of 7.8%, and was higher 82% of the time. That's compared to an average anytime six-month return of 4.2%, with a win rate of just 74%. A year out, the S&P 500 was up 15.3%, on average, and higher nearly every time! For comparison, the index has averaged an annual return of 8.7% since 1987, and has been positive 78% of the time.

SPX after AAII signals vs anytime

In conclusion, while several macro events could impact stocks -- the Fed being the biggest wildcard, per Schaeffer's Senior V.P. of Research Todd Salamone -- it seems we haven't yet hit the "euphoria" phase of the sentiment cycle that marks market tops. As such, contrarians can find comfort in the old adage that "markets advance on a wall of worry and decline on a slope of hope" -- a theory supported by the AAII data above.

A Schaeffer's exclusive!

The Expert's Guide

Access your FREE trading earning announcements before it's too late!



NEW! Explore Schaeffer’s Partners' deals and get connected to top online brokerages with deals tailored exclusively for our readers.  Get answers to your questions regarding transfer fees, commission rates, programs and available discounts related to online trading services.

MORE | MARKETstories

Research Exposes Shortcut to Stock Market Wins
A simple way to stop picking losers, and start cashing in like Wall Street's elite.
Cannabis Stock Rally Cut Short after Downgrade
Aurora Cannabis did receive a price-target hike from Jefferies, though
Vaccines, China Trigger Roller Coaster Week for Stocks
Moderna's vaccine captured the attention of Wall Street
Research Exposes Shortcut to Stock Market Wins
A simple way to stop picking losers, and start cashing in like Wall Street's elite.