Bad Week for Transport Stocks Could Have Big Implications

How the DJI and DJT indexes perform after a big weekly divergence

by Andrea Kramer

Published on Jan 26, 2018 at 10:34 AM

Transport stocks have taken a hit this week, following some lackluster airline earnings. As such, the Dow Jones Transportation Average (DJT) is pacing for a weekly loss of more than 2%. Considering the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJI) is headed for a weekly win, some Dow Theory followers could be getting nervous at the divergence. Below, we take a look at how the transports and blue-chip indexes perform after going different directions.

Just the Second Transports Signal Since 2006

The last time the DJT was down more than 2% for the week at the same time the DJI was up at least 1% was in late July 2017. Prior to that, you'd have to go back to July 2006 for a signal. In fact, it's interesting to note that the last four signals occurred in the month of July. The year with the most signals was 1998 -- during the height of the dot-com boom -- with three. Since 1919, there have been just 23 such signals of DJT/DJI divergence, according to data from Schaeffer's Senior Quantitative Analyst Rocky White.

transports underperform weekly since 1919

Short-Term Underperformance, Volatility Ahead?

Looking at Transports and Dow returns after signals shows that both sides tend to underperform in the short term, and volatility is higher than usual across the board, as evidenced by the Standard Deviation columns in the charts below. One week after a signal, the DJI was down 1.39%, on average, and the DJT was down 1.19%. Both indexes were positive just 35% of the time. That's compared to average anytime one-week gains of 0.14%, with respective win rates of 57% and 53%.

A month after signals, the DJI and DJT were both down close to 0.2%, on average, compared to average anytime four-week gains of about 0.6%. The DJI was higher 48% of the time, and the DJT was higher 35% of the time -- underperforming their average anytime win rates of 59% and 57%, respectively.

However, it's worth noting that both the DJI and DJT tend to outperform looking three and six months after signals. Specifically, the blue-chip barometer was up 2.43% and 4.15%, on average, three and six months out, respectively, compared to average anytime gains of 1.87% and 3.72%. The DJT was higher 4.49%, on average, three months after a signal -- more than doubling its average anytime gain of 2.03%.

DJI after Transports signal

DJT after Transports signal

In conclusion, if past is prologue, we could expect some short-term underperformance for both the industrial average and Dow Transports, and more volatility than usual. However, the long-term returns look promising for DJI and DJT, and a separate transports signal earlier this month could also bode well for stocks, if history repeats.

Streaming Stock Sees a Pre-Earnings Lift
Roku stock is well into overbought territory
2 Energy Stocks That Could Fizzle
Crude oil prices are flirting with YTD highs, but these stocks could dip
What to Make of Rising Analyst Buy Ratings
The percentage of "buy" ratings on SPX stocks just surpassed the 2014 peak
START YOUR DAY SMARTER.

Get Schaeffer's pre-market news bulletin every morning before the bell rings.
It's free to sign up.


Partnercenter


NEW! Explore Schaeffer’s Partners' deals and get connected to top online brokerages with deals tailored exclusively for our readers.  Get answers to your questions regarding transfer fees, commission rates, programs and available discounts related to online trading services.

MORE | MARKETstories


Man Who Issued 2008 Warning Urging Investors to Act Now
The time to invest is now, according to one economist.
Call Volume Surges During KNDI, BLNK Stock Rallies
Meanwhile, SCHW is in the red after a downgrade
CODI Stock Trims Early Gains After Tilray Deal
The company just sold its hemp foods unit Manitoba Harvest to weed giant Tilray
Man Who Issued 2008 Warning Urging Investors to Act Now
The time to invest is now, according to one economist.