The Volatility Clue You May Have Missed

The S&P 500 Index could get stuck around another magnetic half-century level on the charts

by Todd Salamone

Published on Feb 27, 2017 at 8:36 AM
Updated on Feb 27, 2017 at 8:40 AM

"...  [XIV] comes into the week between 65 and 70 -- an area that could prove pivotal... when the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX - 11.49) moves lower, this ETN will advance, and vice versa. And last week, XIV burst above the 66 level -- double its November low -- but pulled back fairly rapidly from Wednesday's peak just shy of 70. In September and October, XIV peaked in the 40 area, which is double the June 2016 closing low. The September and October XIV peaks in the 40 area were also 50% above the 2015 close. The XIV's peak close at 69.81 last week is 50% above its 2016 close of 46.75, which makes the action in this ETN much like that when it peaked in September and October last year."
    -- Monday Morning Outlook, February 21, 2017


The CBOE Volatility Index (VIX - 11.47) was flat last week and -- since early January -- has traded sideways with lows mostly in the 11.25 area, which represents half its pre-election closing peak at 22.50. But the VelocityShares Daily Inverse VIX Short-Term ETN (XIV - 64.52), which we discussed a week ago in this space, pulled back from an area that we observed could act as resistance -- specifically, double its November low and 50% above its 2015 close, as you can see in the chart below.

As we head into this week's trading, note that XIV touched its 30-day moving average on Friday morning -- a trendline that it has not closed below since the November bottom. Volatility expectations rose and stocks sold off mildly after Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin indicated on Thursday that the economic growth impact from new policies will not be felt until 2018. But this action was short-lived, as both stocks and the XIV rose from their Friday morning lows. Unlike late November and late December, though, the XIV's 20-day moving average did not support the XIV pullback -- which could be a clue that volatility expectations are set to move higher.

Nothing has changed with respect to the risk of a volatility pop, with large speculators -- who have been wrong at major turning points in volatility -- still in an extreme short position on VIX futures, per the weekly Commitments of Traders (CoT) report. Additionally, Schaeffer's founder and chairman, Bernie Schaeffer, detailed mounting evidence for a volatility spike in an article entitled, "Is This An Inflection Point For Equity Volatility?

The good news is that while the XIV declined from resistance, stocks carved out new highs into Thursday. Last week's action in the XIV and S&P 500 Index (SPX - 2,367.34) is fascinating in that one could have made money on an XIV short used to hedge a long portfolio, as the XIV declined coincident with stocks rising.

xiv daily 20 day moving average 0224


With all eyes on the White House's forthcoming proposal for tax reform, the prospect of potential hints as to what's coming when President Donald Trump addresses Congress on Tuesday, a Fed meeting in March, Brexit back on the radar, and French elections in April, equity volatility still has more upside than downside potential.


Last week, I reminded you that that one noteworthy historical pattern of the SPX is that it tends to respect half-century mark levels, such as 2,250 and 2,350. For example, after an early December move above 2,250, the SPX did not stray too far above this level, trading sideways in the final three weeks of the month and retesting 2,250 a few times into mid-January.

Another level that came on my radar this past week, thanks to the Bloomberg report linked in the tweet above, is that the SPX reached Wall Street strategists' average target for 2017 when it rallied to 2,364. There is nothing magical about 2,364, other than it represents an average of forecasts. Note, therefore, that not a single strategist necessarily has a target of 2,364. But with this number likely on the radar of some market participants and fixed less than 1% above the 2,350 mark, an SPX hesitation in the 2,350 zone could resemble the mid-December through mid-January action around 2,250.

spx daily chart half century levels 0224


"A tailwind for this rally has been the bearish positioning of investors, with fund managers persistently shunning equities in exchange for holding cash... That's no longer the case. Fund managers became bullish again in December, and remain so now. Optimism towards the economy has surged to a 2-year high. Cash remains in favor (a positive) but global equity allocations are back above neutral for the first time since late 2015. Another push higher and excessive bullish sentiment will become a headwind. The US is the most overweighted equity market on a relative basis."
    -- The Fat Pitch blog, February 15, 2017

The obvious is that there are myriad possibilities, and this is exactly how you should approach the current environment. One could argue that the SPX moves sideways in the 2,350-2,365 zone, much like the action in mid-December through mid-January.

I have mentioned the risk of a volatility pop as pre-election pessimism continues to give way to optimism. There has been massive short covering, and once-skeptical fund managers have changed their tune toward a more positive outlook. Now, the SPX trades 67 points, or 3%, above the round 2,300 century mark -- site of its 30-day moving average. This trendline could play "catch up" if it stalls again in the coming weeks, or contain a pullback similar to that which occurred at the end of December into January.

But momentum tends to beget momentum, and there were a couple of times last week when sellers emerged, but buyers quickly overwhelmed them. While you should be aware of the risks discussed above, you should not be "fighting the tape," either. I continue to advise recognizing the risk by employing option strategies, such as the stock replacement strategy, in which you sell a stock position and buy calls on the underlying to reduce your dollar risk in the market but still partake in upside momentum in a leveraged manner.

If you are in commodities, the energy and copper sectors are among those with the greatest risk, as CoT large speculators are extremely long copper and oil futures contracts amid so-so price action.

However, gold continues to be a sector within the commodities market that I like, given its strong price action this year. This occurs after this once-crowded trade has become much less crowded. For example, net long positions among large speculators on gold futures are down nearly 50% since the 2016 peak -- and this is a group that was overly optimistic on gold into the election and bailed just in time for this year's advance.

cot large speculators gold net positions 0224


Continue reading:


Get Bernie Schaeffer's latest stock market insights direct to your inbox, every Sunday morning, with our free Chart of the Week newsletter.

A Schaeffer's exclusive

11 Stocks to Buy Before Leap Day

Access your FREE insider report before it's too late!


 
 

Partnercenter


NEW! Explore Schaeffer’s Partners' deals and get connected to top online brokerages with deals tailored exclusively for our readers.  Get answers to your questions regarding transfer fees, commission rates, programs and available discounts related to online trading services.

MORE | MARKETstories


IRA/401K Investment Guide: 2019 Stock Market Crash
Use gold to protect any IRA, 401(k), or retirement account from a looming financial crisis.
Final Week of February Brings Fresh Round of Earnings, GDP Data
Earnings season will end with a bang, as several retailers to report
MGM Resorts Stock Falls Victim to Data Breach
MGM has had a difficult start to February
IRA/401K Investment Guide: 2019 Stock Market Crash
Use gold to protect any IRA, 401(k), or retirement account from a looming financial crisis.