Indicator of the Week: Analysts Are Losing Faith … Should You?

The percentage of 'buy' ratings among S&P 500 Index (SPX) components is dwindling, even with stocks trending higher

by Rocky White

Published on May 13, 2015 at 6:15 AM
Updated on May 13, 2015 at 8:20 AM

Last week, I took an in-depth look at the Investors Intelligence (II) sentiment survey.  That analysis showed a lot of published stock market advisors were bullish on the stock market, and very few were outright bearish.  This week, I'll try to gauge the sentiment from brokers. 

The data comes from Zacks and shows the number of "buy," "hold," and "sell" recommendations for each stock.  I aggregated the data to see the total percentage of "buy" recommendations.  The assumption is that when the total percentage of "buy" recommendations is high, brokers are bullish.  When it's low, they are bearish.

Total Percent "Buys":  Here's a chart of the S&P 500 Index (SPX) going back to 1996, along with the percentage of "buys" for SPX components.  Note that the stocks used are current stocks in the S&P.  Ideally, I'd like to use the stock components on the record date, but unfortunately I don't have the list of stocks for each date, and getting that data would be more work than it's worth.  However, I'm confident the chart would not change too significantly if I did have that data. 


As you can see, at the height of the tech boom, over 70% of broker recommendations were "buys." Brokers were essentially telling you to buy anything; you were bound to make money.  That all changed, of course, after the crash.  Since then, the "buy" percentage has never come close to that level, ranging from 44% to 58%.  Currently, for S&P 500 stocks, 51.2% of recommendations are "buys."  

Below is the same chart, but zoomed in to show just the last 10 years.  The percentage of "buys" peaked in late 2011, and despite the strong stock returns since then, the number of "buy" recommendations is declining.  From a contrarian point of view, the waning optimism among brokers, juxtaposed against the upward trend of the market, is a very bullish sign.  


A Schaeffer's exclusive!

The Expert's Guide

Access your FREE trading earning announcements before it's too late!



NEW! Explore Schaeffer’s Partners' deals and get connected to top online brokerages with deals tailored exclusively for our readers.  Get answers to your questions regarding transfer fees, commission rates, programs and available discounts related to online trading services.

MORE | MARKETstories

Legendary Stock-Picker Calls Top Stock of 2020
Matt McCall's picks were met with disbelief... Until five soared over 1,000%. Get his latest 2020 pick.
Patent Lawsuit Loss Sends AMRN Stock Spiraling
Amarin just lost a major U.S. patent lawsuit for its heart drug Vascepa
RH Stock Sinks Despite Earnings Beat
J.P. Morgan Securities and Cowen and Company cut their price targets
The Latest Investor's Guide to Precious Metals
Learn how to protect savings and maximize returns by investing in precious metals.