Monday Morning Outlook: Despite Long-Term Uptrend, Bearish Sentiment Prevails

SPX continues to test its 80-week moving average

by Todd Salamone 9/26/2009 3:45 PM


Housing data, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), and the Group of 20, oh my! Last week's data deluge nearly sent the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) careening into the 10,000 level for the first time since Oct. 7, 2008, but the bulls quickly ran out of steam following the FOMC's policy statement. As a result, the DJIA peaked less than 100 points shy of 10K on Wednesday, and spent the rest of the week careening lower. Looking for a leg up on the coming week, Todd Salamone, Senior Vice President of Research, reviews key sentiment indicators, including the CBOE Market Volatility Index (VIX) and the 20-day historical volatility for the S&P 500 Index (SPX). Todd zeroes in on key support and resistance levels for the SPX and the Russell 2000 Index (RUT), offering levels to keep an eye on heading into next week. Then, Senior Quantitative Analyst Rocky White drills down on historical data concerning fourth-quarter seasonality for the Dow, revealing that Santa Claus may yet be paying a visit to Wall Street. Finally, we wrap up with a look at some key economic and earnings reports slated for release this week.

Recap of the Previous Week: Fed Fails to Inspire Bulls
By Joseph Hargett, Senior Equities Analyst

It was a roller coaster week for the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA), with the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) providing the lift hill for a plunge heading into the weekend. Stocks surrendered to widespread selling pressure right out of the gate on Monday, as lackluster leading economic indicators and profit taking ahead of the FOMC and Group of 20 (G20) meetings drove the Dow to a loss of 0.42%. On Tuesday, a round of solid earnings reports and rising commodities prices (due to a falling U.S. dollar) more than negated Monday's losses, as traders turned cautiously optimistic heading into the FOMC statement on monetary policy. The DJIA rebounded 0.52% as a result.

Wednesday marked the beginning of the end for the bulls on the week. The Fed reported that economic activity had "picked up" since its last meeting, but that it would maintain rock-bottom interest rates near zero for some time, and announced plans to extend its purchase of mortgage-backed securities into early 2010. Furthermore, the Fed said it expects inflation to remain "subdued." The Dow looked poised to challenge the 10,000 level shortly after the statement, but an eleventh-hour sell-off plunged the blue-chip barometer 0.83% into the red. Stronger-than-expected weekly jobless claims promised to send stocks back the other direction on Thursday, but a disappointing report from the National Association of Realtors quickly spoiled the mood on the Street. According to the data, existing home sales staggered 2.7% lower in August, reversing course after a 7.2% rise in July. The Dow fell 0.42% on the day.

Stocks slid into the red for the third straight session on Friday, as investors digested disappointing earnings from Research In Motion Limited (RIMM) and a wave of dismal economic data. Specifically, durable goods orders fell by a steeper-than-expected 2.4% in August and new home sales all but flatlined for the month, although consumer sentiment sprinted past economists' predictions to approach 21-month highs. Still, the Dow fell 0.44% on the day, ending the week with a loss of 1.6%. Elsewhere, the S&P 500 Index (SPX) dropped 2.2% last week, while the Nasdaq Composite (COMP) fell 2% on a week-over-week basis.

What the Trader Is Expecting in the Coming Week: Battling Conventional Wisdom
By Todd Salamone, Senior Vice President of Research

"The odds are stacked against the market for the upcoming week when looking at quadruple-witching week-after returns since 2006. However, we remain bullish in the context of an improving technical backdrop and a sentiment landscape that suggests 'disbelief.'"
- Monday Morning Outlook, Sept. 19, 2009

Stocks behaved as expected in the week following quadruple-witching expiration, with the market suffering the typical post-expiration hangover by trading lower in four of the five days. Put demand was predominant on broad-based indexes and exchange-traded funds (ETFs), especially the S&P 500 Index (SPX), the iShares Russell 2000 Index Fund (IWM), and the Standard & Poor's Depositary Receipts (SPY). Furthermore, the CBOE Market Volatility Index (VIX) rose, as demand for portfolio protection grew.

Conventional wisdom thinks that stocks are overdue for a big pullback and that portfolio protection is cheap, so growing put demand was not a huge surprise. What's more, as I discussed last week, the mechanics of growing demand for portfolio protection usually has a depressive effect on stocks. This effect usually occurs immediately following expiration, as investors replace expired put hedges. If you combine the bearish mechanics of index and ETF put buying, last week's short-term "overbought" condition, the prospects of stimulus removal as suggested by the G20 and Fed meetings, and disappointing reports on housing and durable goods, you are left with difficult market headwinds.

However, the pullback may generate another buying opportunity, as the indexes retreated to potential support areas. The "buying opportunity" view is consistent with the current trend in the market, but inconsistent with the outlook of many traders and investors.

In addition to the common view that a sharp pullback could be on the horizon, many professionals agree that portfolio protection (a la the VIX) is "cheap and headed higher." While it is true that the VIX is trading near its 52-week lows, it should also be noted that the 20-day historical volatility of the SPX is only 14.8%. In other words, the VIX can easily be considered expensive when compared to SPX historical volatility. In fact, the VIX is currently trading more than 75% above SPX historical volatility. During the past five years, the VIX has typically traded at a 25% premium to historical volatility, suggesting that a reading of 18 might be considered normal relative to current historical volatility. Finally, the VIX comes into the week just below its 80-day moving average, a trendline that has marked peaks dating back to mid-January. This trendline could mark yet another top in the near future. As I stated in early September, "The contrarian bet for the months of September and October is a neutral-to-bearish trade on volatility."



Daily chart of the VIX with 80-day moving average

We are still intrigued by the skepticism or, put another way, the vast sideline money that exists within the context of the huge rally off the March lows. Last weekend, Barron's summed up the sentiment landscape perfectly, with a cover and byline that read, "THE NEW INVESTOR – Even with shares up sharply, millions of Americans remain fearful and may stay that way for years, clinging to cash, bonds and dividend-paying stocks."

Meanwhile, the American Association of Individual Investors' (AAII) poll continues to reflect prevalent fear and defensive posturing. In the last AAII survey, only 39% of retail investors surveyed were bullish on stocks, compared to nearly 45% bearish. The fact that there are more bears than bulls is astonishing. Moreover, the market rally has coexisted with anxiety among retail investors for the past 10 weeks. During this 10-week period, in which the SPX rallied nearly 8%, the average bullish percentage was only 39%, while the average bearish percentage was 40% – again, more bears than bulls.

The SPX moved out of its short-term "overbought" condition, but now sits back below its 80-week moving average as we enter the week ahead. Last week, I raised the possibility that this trendline could serve as short-term support in the event of a pullback. If a move back above the important 80-week moving average is not achieved in fairly short order, expect buyers to emerge around the 1,000 area. This region is home to a trendline connecting the March and July lows. A move up to 1,120 would mark a 50% retracement of the SPX's October 2007 high and its March trough, so this would be the next upside target for the bulls.



Weekly chart of the SPX with 80-week moving average

Finally, the RUT pulled back to the 600 area last week. As I have previously discussed, 600 is significant, as it is the site of the RUT's March 2000 high and a 50% retracement of the index's July 2007 peak and March low. The RUT's 80-month moving average is situated at 634.52, and could be a challenge, having provided support on a monthly closing basis in October 1998 and in September/October 2001.



Monthly chart of the RUT with 80-month moving average since 1995

Today's Most Popular Stories




Featured Companies





Receive FREE access to Schaeffer’s
Sentiment Spring 2009
premier online options magazine!



Partner Center